Shoofly Pie is a Special Pie that can be selected by players to be the "Special of the Day" in Papa's Bakeria. Customers coming in can choose this special instead of their regular order. Customers who ask for the Shoofly Pie will give the player 2.5x 
. The special prize for this recipe is the Groovy Headband.
Recipe
| Crust | Creameo Crust |
|---|---|
| Pie Filling | Toffee Filling |
| Toffee Filling | |
| Toffee Filling | |
| Toffee Filling | |
| Top Crust | Polka Dot Crust |
| Toppings | Chocolate Mousse (Outer Ring) |
Trivia
- Shoofly Pie is based off a real life dessert. It is named so because of its sweet odor that attracts flies that must be "shooed".
- Sticker 65 " Try Some Toffee" is earned by serving Shoofly Pie to Prudence.
Gallery
Prize
Carlo Romano and Georgito with a perfect Shoofly Pie
| v • e Papa's Bakeria/To Go! Specials | |
|---|---|
| Special Pies | Apple Crisp • Banana Cream • Banana Split • Banoffee Pie • Caramel Apple • Cherry Cheesecake • Cherry Cordial • Citri-Shock • Cloud Nine • Cocoa Key Lime • Creameo Cheesecake • Derby Pie • Fluffernutter • French Silk • Graceland King • Granny Smith • Kiwi Strawberry • Lemon Meringue • Luau Punch • Mallow Haupia • Mississippi Mud • Neapolitan Pie • Nutty Buttercup • Orchard Tart • Peach Cobbler • Pineapple Upside Down • Pink Lemonade • Piña Coolada • Plantain Crunch • Prune Creek • Rhuby Tuber • Rocky Road • Royal Anne • S'mores Pie • Shoofly Pie • Southern Pecan • Sugar Dragon • Strawberry Rhubarb • Tiramisu • Wild Berry |