
In Papa's Freezeria To Go!, Key Lime Topping is unlocked with Mitch on Rank 49. The badge "Time for Lime" is received when this is served 30 times.
In Papa's Donuteria, Key Lime Drizzle is an holiday-exclusive drizzle available during St. Paddy's Day. It's unlocked on Day 6 of the holiday.
In Papa's Bakeria, Key Lime Filling is a standard pie filling unlocked with Mitch on Rank 19.
Customers who order this (Freezeria To Go!)
Customers who order this (Donuteria)

- Georgito
- Gino Romano
- Julep
- Mayor Mallow
- Skyler
- Rudy (Closer)
- Quinn (Closer)
- Xolo (Closer)
Customers who order this filling (Bakeria)

Specials that use this ingredient
Papa's Bakeria
Trivia:
- Hope is the only female customer to order Key Lime Filling in Papa's Bakeria.