A Closer is a special type of customer who is very picky that comes at the end of the day. Closers made their first appearance in Papa's Taco Mia! Each closer is scheduled to come in on the same day every week. Starting Papa's Freezeria, the closer who appears on Mondays is a local of wherever the Gameria takes place. Closers have always liked every holiday since its introduction in Papa's Cupcakeria.
Since holidays were introduced in Papa's Cupcakeria, the closers dress up in costumes during the Halloween season.
- Trishna: Princess
- Radlynn: Radley Madish
- Xolo: Clown
- Mayor Mallow: Ghost
- Quinn: Cat
- Kenji: Luchador
- Jojo: Superhero
- Whiff: Viking
- Emmlette: Chick
- Quinn and Jojo have both been closers since Papa's Taco Mia!
- Upon seeing a closer coming in, the "Take Order" button and talk bubbles will be red and zaggy, and their names will have a red highlight.
- There are often three male (excluding Jojo, since he is the Food Critic) and three female closers in each game since closers were first introduced. The only exceptions are in Papa's Burgeria HD/To Go!, where there are four male and two female closers.
- Closers never go to the dining area nor seen joining any of the regular customers.
- Closers do not appear in the Customer Cravings mini game.
- The first closer to appear on Day 2 is always a local, with the exception of Robby in Papa's Taco Mia!/HD.
- Closers don't order specials.
- In Papa's Bakeria, Mayor Mallow and Rhonda are the only closers to have stickers by serving them a special:
- In Papa's Sushiria, Xolo is the only one to have a sticker by serving them a special:
- "Serve a Kiwi Kosho special to Xolo"